Operational Technology Security
What is OT?
OT or Operational Technology encompasses the hardware and software systems used to monitor and control physical processes, devices, and infrastructure. Unlike IT (Information Technology), which focuses on data processing and storage, OT deals with real-world operations, making its security a vital subset of overall cybersecurity efforts.
What is OT Security?
OT security refers to the practices and technologies used to protect operational technology systems from cyberthreats. This includes ICS (Industrial Control Systems), SCADA (Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition) systems, PLCs (Programmable Logic Controllers), DCS (Distributed Control Systems), and other systems that manage and automate industrial processes.
Examples of OT components found in various sectors:
ICS
Automated systems that manage the operations of industrial processes.
SCADA Systems
Networks of hardware and software that collect and analyse real-time data to monitor and control industrial equipment.
PLCs
Industrial digital computers that are used to control manufacturing processes such as assembly lines and robotic devices.
IT vs. OT Security
Area of Focus
IT security primarily aims to protect data integrity, confidentiality, and availability. It focuses on safeguarding digital information, securing networks, and ensuring user privacy. On the other hand, OT security prioritizes the safety, reliability, and operational continuity of physical systems. While IT security protects data, OT security ensures the functionality of machinery and infrastructure.
The Nature of Assets
IT assets include data, software, networks, and user devices. OT assets encompass physical systems like manufacturing equipment, power grids, transportation systems, and critical infrastructure.
Threat Landscape
IT systems face threats such as malware, email phishing, data breaches, and insider attacks. While these attacks can certainly “live off the land” to gain access to critical OT assets thanks to the IT/OT convergence, OT systems are additionally vulnerable to threats like sabotage, industrial espionage, and cyber-physical attacks that can disrupt operations and cause physical harm.
OT networks are unique because they often employ air gaps, which are security measures that isolate a network from unsecured networks, particularly the public internet, to prevent unauthorized access. Despite these precautions, updating legacy OT systems typically requires removable media, essential for maintaining and upgrading critical assets, but also poses a significant security risk. The use of removable media bypasses traditional network security measures, potentially introducing malware and other threats directly into the OT environment, compromising the integrity and safety of these critical systems.
Security Approaches
IT security employs tools like antivirus software, firewalls, email security, and encryption. IT prioritizes confidentiality of its systems. OT security strategies tend to focus more heavily on network segmentation, asset visibility, scanning USBs and portable media, and other security measures to prevent unexpected shutdowns of production equipment and processes.
Compliance and Regulations
Regulations tend to echo these priorities, IT security is governed by regulations such as GDPR, HIPAA, and PCI-DSS, which focus on data protection and privacy. OT security is subject to industry-specific standards like NIST SP 800-82, IEC 62443, and ISO/IEC 27019, NERC CIP, NIS2, Executive Orders, and other regulations that address the security of industrial control systems and critical infrastructure—often prioritizing the reliability of these systems.
Risk Management
IT risk management centres on protecting data and ensuring business continuity. OT risk management emphasizes the safety and reliability of physical operations, often prioritizing human safety and environmental protection over data confidentiality.
Threats to OT Security
OT systems face a unique set of cybersecurity threats that can have severe consequences. As they become more interconnected and integrated with IT systems, they too become more vulnerable to a variety of new threat vectors. The consequences of compromised OT security can be far-reaching, affecting not only the operations and profitability of businesses but also posing significant risks to public safety and national security. Common OT security threats include:
-
Malware
Attacks like Conficker exploit network vulnerabilities and spread via removable media, making it dangerous for OT infrastructure by crossing the air gap and disrupting critical operations, as seen in the 2008 attack on the UK's Ministry of Defence systems.
-
Ransomware
Attacks that lock down critical systems until a ransom is paid, like the WannaCry attack that affected the UK's National Health Service.
-
Insider Threats
Employees or contractors with malicious intent or who inadvertently compromise security through negligence.
-
Nation-State Threat Actors
State-sponsored and well-coordinated attack plans often with political motivation
Real-World Incidents
These threats aren't empty ones or hypothetical—they're very real. Here are just a few modern examples of high-profile cyberattacks that could have potentially been stopped with a larger emphasis on OT security:
Stuxnet - 2010
A sophisticated cyber weapon that targeted Iran's nuclear program that caused physical damage to centrifuges.
Ukrainian Power Grid Attack - 2015
A cyberattack that caused a power outage for over 200,000 people, demonstrating the vulnerability of critical infrastructure.
Aliquippa Water Infiltration - 2023
The Iranian-backed CyberAv3ngers hacker group managed to gain control over a booster station responsible for monitoring and regulating pressure, threatening the drinking water supply.
Potential Consequences of Compromised OT Security
When critical OT networks are compromised, the effects are far-reaching and can significantly impact various aspects of an organization's operations and the broader community. Ensuring the integrity and security of OT systems is essential to preventing a range of adverse outcomes, including but not limited to:
Risks to Public Safety
Compromised OT systems can lead to hazardous conditions, endangering lives and the environment. For instance, a cyber-physical attack on a water treatment facility could contaminate the water supply, posing serious health risks to the public. Similarly, disruptions in industrial control systems could lead to uncontrolled release of hazardous materials, fires, or explosions.
Disruption in Manufacturing
The disruption of manufacturing processes can have implications far beyond financial losses. For example, if the production of a critical vaccine is interrupted, it could delay immunization efforts during a health crisis, exacerbating the spread of disease. Additionally, if a crucial material, such as an alloy, is produced out of specification without detection, it could lead to catastrophic failures in other applications. Imagine a bridge failing because a structural component was more brittle than believed due to compromised manufacturing controls. Such incidents underscore the importance of maintaining rigorous oversight and security in manufacturing operations.
Economic Impact
Widespread outages and disruptions in OT systems can have extensive economic repercussions. The failure to produce or transport goods not only affects the immediate financial health of an organization but also disrupts supply chains, leading to shortages and increased costs for consumers and businesses alike. For example, a cyberattack on a major port could halt the flow of goods, affecting industries worldwide and leading to significant economic instability.
What is IT/OT Convergence?
IT/OT convergence refers to the integration of IT systems with OT systems for improved efficiency, data sharing, and decision-making. This convergence is driven by advancements in technology, such as the IIoT (Industrial Internet of Things), big data analytics, and cloud computing.
Challenges
New Security Vulnerabilities
Increased connectivity introduces new attack vectors.
Complexity in System Management
Integrating disparate systems requires careful planning and coordination.
Benefits
Improved Efficiency
Streamlined operations and better resource management.
Enhanced Decision-Making
Real-time data analytics enable informed decision-making.
Cost Savings
Reduced operational costs through automation and predictive maintenance.
Key Components
Unified Architecture
A common framework that integrates IT and OT systems.
Advanced Analytics
Tools to analyse data from both IT and OT environments.
Robust Security Measures
Comprehensive security strategies to protect integrated systems.
Best Practices for OT Cybersecurity
Considering the challenges presented by an evolving threat landscape, effective OT cybersecurity is essential for protecting critical infrastructure and ensuring the uninterrupted operation of industrial systems. By adhering to best practices, organizations can significantly reduce the risk of cyberattacks and mitigate potential damage. The following sections outline key strategies and practices for enhancing OT cybersecurity, including thorough risk assessments, essential cybersecurity practices, and the development of a defence-in-depth security framework.
Key Cybersecurity Concepts
Peripheral and Removable Media Security
Enforce strict scanning security policies for removable media, like USB storage devices at every point of entry—from lobby to endpoint.
Segmentation
Isolate OT networks from IT networks to limit the spread of malware.
Network Perimeter Security
Granularly control data traffic in real-time between networks with data diodes and security gateways.
Supply Chain Security
Disruption of the supply chain can cause a domino effect—where an exploited vulnerability can eventually be felt further down the chain, leading to substantial damage.
Patch Management
Regularly update software and firmware on critical assets to fix security vulnerabilities.
Risk Assessment
Regularly review and update risk management plans to address emerging threats.
Implementing a Defence-in-Depth OT Security Framework
A well-structured security framework not only protects critical infrastructure but also ensures the resilience and continuity of industrial operations. The following five steps provide a comprehensive guide to developing and implementing an effective OT security framework, focusing on assessing current security measures, establishing policies, deploying controls, educating staff, and maintaining continuous monitoring.
The Importance of Compliance with Standards and Regulations
Adhering to industry standards and regulations is critical for ensuring that OT security measures are comprehensive and up to date. Compliance not only helps in mitigating risks and protecting critical infrastructure but also ensures that organizations meet legal and regulatory requirements, which can prevent costly fines and legal actions. Three key standards and regulatory frameworks relevant to OT security are the NIST (National Institute of Standards and Technology) guidelines, the IEC (International Electrotechnical Commission) standards, and the NERC CIP (North American Electric Reliability Corporation Critical Infrastructure Protection) standards.
Operational Technology refers to hardware and software systems designed to monitor and control physical devices, processes, and events in various sectors like manufacturing, energy, and utilities. Unlike IT, OT directly affects the physical world.
As industries increasingly use automated and connected technology, ensuring the security of OT systems becomes crucial. Security breaches can lead to severe consequences including operational disruptions, financial losses, and risks to human safety.
IT security primarily focuses on protecting data and maintaining confidentiality, integrity, and availability. OT security, however, is centred around ensuring the safe and reliable operation of physical processes and machinery, with a stronger emphasis on availability and safety.
Examples include ransomware attacks on critical infrastructure, such as the infamous attack on the Colonial Pipeline, and malware targeting industrial control systems like the Stuxnet virus.
OT security regulations vary by industry and region, but common standards include the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) for the energy sector, and the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) standards for industrial automation systems.
Risk assessment in OT involves identifying vulnerabilities in physical devices and software, evaluating the potential impacts of these vulnerabilities, and determining mitigation strategies. This often includes regular system audits and adherence to industry-specific security standards.
Risk assessment in OT involves identifying vulnerabilities in physical devices and software, evaluating the potential impacts of these vulnerabilities, and determining mitigation strategies. This often includes regular system audits and adherence to industry-specific security standards.
Improving incident response involves establishing a dedicated security team, developing incident handling protocols, conducting regular security drills, and employing continuous monitoring tools to detect and respond to threats promptly.
Converging IT and OT can lead to optimized business processes, improved efficiency, enhanced data collection and analysis capabilities, and ultimately, a stronger competitive edge in the market.
Technologies like artificial intelligence and machine learning are increasingly used to predict and mitigate security threats in real-time. Blockchain technology is also being explored for its potential to secure device-to-device transactions and communications in industrial environments.
Staff training should focus on specific security policies, the use of protective technologies, and the best practices for operating and maintaining OT systems securely. Regular training sessions and drills can help reinforce these practices.
